Writing as a Primary Means for Learning—Ruth Ann Atchley
Student responding to in-class writing prompt
Background |
Implementation |
Observations |
Reflections |
Comments
Student Performance
Every single student's writing improved. This has not happened
in any other class I have taught.
The content appeared to be learned as well as would occur in a
lecture setting. In their feedback, students insisted that they
learned a great deal. But I am still unsure what can be used to
objectively measure their learning.
I can't create a mastery list, as this material doesn't lend itself
to single answers. There is no concrete material that I can scrutinize,
and as a neuroscientist used to teaching facts, this is disconcerting.
I don't think that I will ever be 100% confident of the success
or outcome from this method of teaching.
When students are forced to write a very concise answer to a relatively
broad question, students who understand the concepts can write
in a clear, comprehensive manner. Conversely, they don't understand
the concepts, their writing becomes vague, flowery, or imprecise.